
Hudson Valley ‘Doc’ Killed After Upstate New York Party By Friend
A Hudson Valley found guilty of killing his friend after a wild night of drinking has learned his punishment.
In Ulster County Court, 39-year-old Joseph Karolys, age 39, of Saugerties, was sentenced to 25 years in State Prison.
Maximum Sentenced Issued In Ulster County Court
Karolys received the maximum sentence after a jury convicted the 39-year-old of first-degree manslaughter, first-degree assault and tampering with physical evidence after just two hours of deliberations.
Warning: 'Aggressive" Bear Destroys Home In Upstate New York, Returns
“This sentence reflects Joseph Karolys’ selfishness and lack of decency towards others – such disregard as in his polluting the water supply sources for many families, and stripping Mickey of his life and human dignity by leaving him on the side of the road to die. The impact of this crime in Saugerties is far-reaching; I am hopeful that Mickey’s family and friends in Saugerties will cherish and make a legacy of their memories of him," District Attorney Emmanuel C. Nneji said.
Jurors determined that found that Karolys "acted in concert" with others to intentionally cause serious physical injury to David “Mickey” Myer.
Myer's body was found on the side of Route 32 in October of 2022.
Ulster County Man Killed Following Halloween Party In Greene County, New York
"Mickey was talented in excavating. He was given the nickname 'Doc' because of his surgical precision with heavy equipment," his obituary states.
For all the news that the Hudson Valley is sharing make sure to follow Hudson Valley Post on Facebook, download the Hudson Valley Post Mobile
More Evidence Revealed At Trial
Proof at trial established that Myer was brutally assaulted inside the truck and that Karolys kicked Myer in the head after he was removed from the vehicle and left him in extremis.
"Thereafter he and his son took steps to conceal the crime, including burning the steel-toe boots Karolys used in the crime in their wood stove," the Ulster County DA's office states. "Karolys then took Cummins out of town with him and spent several days moving around the Lake George area as he worked on Cummins to take the rap for him."
Cummins soon turned himself. However, according to the Ulster County DA's office, it was in an attempt to "cover" for Karolys.
Popular Destination In New York State Is Crawling With Bed Bugs
"Eventually Cummins cooperated with the prosecution and revealed information previously unknown in the case," the Ulster County DA"s office stated.
These 12 Armed And Dangerous Men Are Wanted By Police In New York State
Keep Reading:
Most Dangerous Regions To Drive In New York State
Nearly 30 New York Hospitals Earn Near Failing Grade For Patient Safety
More From Hudson Valley Post








