![Over 50 New York Pizzerias Ranked by Barstool’s Dave Portnoy](https://townsquare.media/site/854/files/2021/11/attachment-screenshot-capture-2021-11-15-10-07-46.jpg?w=980&q=75)
Over 50 New York Pizzerias Ranked by Barstool’s Dave Portnoy
When it comes to amazing pizza you don't have to leave New York State. But where can you find the best slice?
![Hudson Valley Post logo](https://townsquare.media/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/hudsonvalleypost.png?w=100)
Dave Portnoy is the founder of Barstool Sports. His now-famous "One Bite Reviews" started in Boston during a debate with a coworker. He agreed if you could only eat one food for the rest of your life pizza would be the best choice. He then started reviewing pizza, which became quite popular including his catchphrase "one bite. everyone knows the rules."
While the debate started in Boston Portnoy now lives in New York. So he has reviewed countless pies from the Empire State. We searched his archives and below of 50 pizzeria's Portnoy reviewed with most coming from the Hudson Valley, Capital Region and New York City area.
Over 50 New York Pizzerias Ranked by Barstool's Dave Portnoy
20 Worst Places to Live in New York State
Barstool's Dave Portnoy Finally Reviews Pizza From Mid-Hudson Valley
Potential Cancer-Causing Chemicals Found in New York Drinking Water
The 26 Most Dangerous Counties in New York State
15 New York Towns Among Safest in America
Top 5 Best Places to Live in New York
While no place in the Hudson Valley made the list, the region has received a ton of praise recently.
Hudson Valley Towns Honored
Village Pizza & Restaurant, Rhinebeck
Score: 7.2
Pizza Sam’s, Jackson Heights
Score: 8.4
Nick’s Pizza, Forest Hills
Score: 8.4
Pizzeria Posto, Rhinebeck
Score: 8.2
Rosa’s Pizza, Maspeth
Score: 7.6
Moby’s, East Hampton
Score: 7.9
Bocce Club Pizza, Buffalo
Score: 7.5
Marabella Pizza, Sunnyside
Score: 7.8
Sal’s Pizzeria, Mamaroneck
Score: 7.7
King Umberto, Elmont
Score: 8.2
De Fazio’s, Troy
Score: 8.2
Kenny’s Castaways, Montauk
Score: 7.4
Baby Luc’s, Brooklyn
Score: 8.2
Luigi’s Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 9.3
P&G Pizza and Deli, Southampton
Score: 7.1
Blade + Salt, Montauk*
Score: 7.5
Pennachio’s, Manorville
Score: 7.5
Venezia Pizza & Pasta, Clifton Park
Score: 7.4
West Ave Pizzeria, Saratoga Springs
Score: 7.3
Mario’s, Massapequa
Score: 6.6
Sam’s Bar and Restaurant, East Hampton
Score: 7.8
Nino’s AQ, Queens
Score: 6.8
Springs Pizza, East Hampton
Score: 5.8
Ruschmeyer’s, Montauk
Score: 7.8
Lombardo’s, Brooklyn
Score: 8.2
Pizza Time Wilton, Saratoga Springs
Score: 6.8
Round Swamp Farm, Montauk
Score: 7.3
Biscossi’s Pizza Time, Ballston Spa
Score: 6.9
Max London’s, Saratoga Springs
Score: 7.4
Pizzeria La Rosa, New Rochelle
Score: 7.9
VIPizza, Bayside
Score: 7.6
Pizza Garden, Flushing
Score: 7.4
Raceway Pizza & Ristorante, Yonkers
Score: 7.4
I Love NY Pizza, New York City
Score: 7.3
Michael’s Pizza, Port Chester
Score: 7.7
Johnny’s Pizzeria, Mount Vernon
Score: 9.1
D’Andrea’s Pizza, Saratoga Springs
Score: 7.2
Flatbread Social, Saratoga Springs
Score: 6.9
Cittanuova, East Hampton
Score: 6.7
Pepperoni’s, East Hampton
Score: 6.7
Paesan’s Pizza, Latham
Score: 7.5
Cascarino’s, Whitestone
Score: 6.8
Village Pizzeria, Floral Park
Score: 6.7
Red Front Pizza, Clifton Park
Score: 6.5
Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities, Montauk
Score: 6.1
Borrelli’s Pop-Up Shop, Manhattan
Score: 7.7
Pizza Village, Montauk
Score: 7.3
Sag Pizza, Sag Harbor
Score: 6.8
Villa Milano, Manhasset
Score: 7.1
Lucia Pizza, Flushing
Score: 7.2
Main Street Pizza Company, Farmingdale
Score: 7.1
Mama Mia’s, Saratoga Springs
Score: 7.4
Krave It, Bayside
Score: 6.8
Dani’s House of Pizza, Kew Gardens
Score: 7.4
Villagio’s Italiano Restaurant, Hartsdale
Score: 7.4
La Capannina, Wainscott
Score: 7.6
Saverio’s Authentic Pizza, Massapequa
Score: 6.8
Trattoria L’incontro, Astoria
Score: 8.4
Giuseppina’s, Brooklyn
Score: 8.1
Freddy’s Pizzeria, Whitestone
Score: 7.3
Picasso’s Pizza, Buffalo
Score: 7.0
Best Pizza & Dive Bar, Amagansett
Score: 8.4
Napoli’s Pizzeria, Malta
Score: 7.5
Sorrento’s, Long Beach
Score: 8.7
Astro Pizza & Felice’s Ristorante, Amagansett
Score: 6.8
Avellino Pizza & Pasta, Hartsdale
Score: 7.5
Battle Hill Tavern, Brooklyn
Score: 7.1
Pizza Chef, Whitestone
Score: 4.2
La Nova Pizzeria, Buffalo*
Score: 7.3
Showfish, Montauk
Score: 7.2
Gino’s, Long Beach
Score: 8.9
7-Eleven, Montauk*
Score: 3.8
Sac’s Place, Queens
Score: 7.5
MEZZE, Forest Hills
Score: 6.8
Venice Pizza & Trattoria, North White Plains
Score: 7.3
Salvatore’s Coal Oven Pizzeria, Port Washington
Score: 7.6
Fierro’s Pizza, East Hampton
Score: 7.4
Stella 34 Trattoria, New York City
Score: 5.6
Rosa’s Pizza, Queens
Score: 7.3
Grand Avenue Pizza, Astoria
Score: 7.9
Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza, Pleasantville
Score: 7.6
Paddock Pizzeria, Saratoga Springs
Score: 4.1
Sunnyside Pizza, Queens
Score: 5.4
Vaccaro’s Pizza, Bellerose
Score: 7.8
Totonno’s, Coney Island
Score: 8.1
Krispy Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 7.8
Amore Pizza, Flushing
Score: 8.1
Rose & Joe’s Italian Bakery, Astoria
Score: 6.8
Nonna’s Pizza, White Plains
Score: 7.8
Primavera Pizza, Montauk
Score: 7.6
Rosario’s, Astoria
Score: 7.7
Brother’s Pizzeria, Staten Island
Score: 7.9
La Manda’s, White Plains
Score: 5.9
Eddie’s Pizza, New Hyde Park
Score: 7.8
Vito’s Slices & Ices, New York City
Score: 7.5
Pennsylvania 6, New York City
Score: 6.2
Sauce Restaurant, New York City
Score: 9.0
Emilio’s of Morris Park, Bronx
Score: 7.3
Pizza Time, Brooklyn
Score: 8.2
Norm’s Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 7.6
Rosa’s Pizza, New York City
Score: 6.8
Justin’s Pizza, Bronx
Score: 6.2
Gino’s, Brooklyn
Score: 7.6
Pizzeria Giove, Staten Island
Score: 8.1
Jet’s Pizza, New York City
Score: 7.4
Lo Duca Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 8.1
Nolita Pizza, New York City
Score: 7.4
Tony’s Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 7.9
Table 87, Brooklyn
Score: 7.7
Tommy’s Pizza, Bronx
Score: 8.6
Paulie Gee’s, Brooklyn
Score: 7.4
sLICe, Long Island City
Score: 8.1
Napoli Pizza & Pasta, Astoria
Score: 7.5
Villa Monte Pizza, Staten Island
Score: 6.7
Little Italy Pizza, New York City
Score: 6.1
Denino’s Pizzeria, Staten Island
Score: 8.1
Sam’s, Brooklyn
Score: 7.4
Nunzio’s, Staten Island
Score: 7.9
Pizza 7, Saratoga Springs
Score: 7.7
Campania, Brooklyn
Score: 7.3
The Original Joe & Pat’s, Staten Island
Score: 8.6
Ciro Pizza Café, Staten Island
Score: 7.9
Pizza Wagon, Brooklyn
Score: 7.4
Carmine’s Pizzeria, Brooklyn
Score: 7.8
Villa Pizza, New York City
Score: 7.1
Via Roma Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 7.9
House of Pizza & Calzone, Brooklyn
Score: 7.3
Siena Pizza, New York City
Score: 6.4
Upside Pizza, New York City
Score: 7.4
Gigino Trattoria, New York City
Score: 7.3
Eleven B, New York City
Score: 7.2
The Longshoreman, Brooklyn
Score: 8.2
Frank & Danny’s, Staten Island
Score: 7.6
Grandma’s Original Pizza, Brooklyn
Score: 7.6
26 Highest Paying Jobs in New York State
Election Results: New York Voters Approve, Deny Major Changes
Hudson Valley Says Goodbye To Over 80 Businesses
Nearly 70 Children Have Recently Gone Missing From New York State
Counties in New York With Most Vehicle vs. Animal Crashes
9 New Fast Food Restaurants Coming to Route 9
Over 30 Red Flags For Anyone Who Claims To Live in Hudson Valley, NY
Hudson Valley Welcomes Nearly 70 New Eateries
5 New York Schools Districts Ranked in Top 10 in America
New York Counties With Highest, Lowest COVID Vaccine Rates
'Hudson Valley's Premier Restaurant, Bar' Opening Newburgh Waterfront Location
All-Time COVID Cases Per County in New York
Help Needed Finding The 39 Most Wanted in New York
Air-Breathing Fish That Eats Animals Found in Hudson Valley, New York
More From Hudson Valley Post
![At Least 4 Tornados Touch Down Across New York State](http://townsquare.media/site/854/files/2021/11/attachment-20211114_081518.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![New York Politician Plans to Change Gov. Mario Cuomo Bridge Name](http://townsquare.media/site/705/files/2020/09/50361915197_2c10b6da41_o.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![New York Teacher Tragically Dies At 33 In Hudson Valley](http://townsquare.media/site/854/files/2016/03/RS9874_78819909-1.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![New York ‘Sexual Predator’ Arrested Again in Hudson Valley](http://townsquare.media/site/854/files/2021/11/attachment-Screenshot-Capture-2021-11-15-06-31-43.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![Where in New York Parents Can Take Child To Get COVID Vaccine](http://townsquare.media/site/705/files/2021/11/attachment-GettyImages-1236330349.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![Light Up The Hudson Valley in 2021 — Show Us Your Brightest and Most Beautiful Holiday Displays](http://townsquare.media/site/241/files/2020/10/featured_1600x1067-3.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![Dave Portnoy From Barstool Hits Another Rhinebeck Pizza Place](http://townsquare.media/site/704/files/2021/11/attachment-portnoy.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![Top Breathtaking Hudson Valley Locations to Capture the Best Fall Foliage](http://townsquare.media/site/988/files/2021/11/attachment-RS14699_526131432.jpg?w=980&q=75)
![Fahnestock Education Center Reopens After Multimillion Dollar Revitalization](http://townsquare.media/site/704/files/2021/11/attachment-Copy-of-Gallery-Size-Template-5.jpg?w=980&q=75)